Is This What Finally Needs To Be Done? Israel must declare its sovereignty west of The Jordan River

Is This What Finally Needs To Be Done?

Israel must declare its sovereignty west of The Jordan River 

Yisrael Shleima

Bibi Netanyahu's speech yesterday at the UN was highly and appropriately critical of the UN and the Palestinian Authority and its terrorist, convicted criminal and fugitive from Justice Arab PA leader, Mahmoud Abbas aka Abu Mazen. Yet, Bibi also put forth the offer of dialogue and co-existence. Abbas' speech, however, was full of calumnies, libels and denigration's. His threat to sue Britain for the Balfour Declaration is comical and shows his absolute bitterness and hatred toward Israel, Jews and any entity that supports them, even from 100 years ago!

The conflict between Israel and the "Palestinians" is really a much larger one, between Israel and the Arab and Muslim world. In essence it can be viewed as a religious battle and a war of civilizations.

After 2,000 years of exile, the Jews have returned home to Israel. The connection between the Jewish people and the Land of Israel cannot be denied, yet this is what the Muslim world continues to do. Yes, Israel has peace treaties with Egypt and Jordan, and yes, there is growing trade between Israel and Arab and Muslim nations. However, in their hearts, many or most Arabs and Muslims despise Israel and pray every day for its demise.

Thus, the question: What should Israel do regarding the Arabs living in Judea and Samaria, the heartland of Israel and the cradle of Jewish civilization? There have been numerous suggestions put forth, none gaining much traction. Martin Sherman's article in Arutz Sheva addresses this issue. He reaches the conclusion and proposes a solution that has been discussed and argued about for decades, yet tossed aside as unworkable. However, it may be the most practical.

Sherman posits:

- Israel cannot continue to rule over a growing and increasingly hostile and radicalized Palestinian Arab population which indoctrinate and commits terror and violence.

- Neither can it, nor should it, allow the establishment of yet another Muslim-majority tyranny. (a terrorist state)

- Nor can it integrate the Arab population who commits terror and violence in Judea-Samaria (and Gaza) into the permanent population of the Jewish state.

Please read the article (linked here), including the last paragraph which contains Sherman's conclusion.

INTO THE FRAY: Obama at the UN - Why he was right...almost

For those who can't stand the suspense, here is the last paragraph:

Accordingly, the only  non-coercive policy that can preserve Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people, and remove the Palestinian-Arabs from Jewish rule,  is to set up a system of economic inducements, entailing enticing incentives for them to leave, together with daunting disincentives to stay, and provide non-belligerents and their families an opportunity for a better life elsewhere out of harm's way. That is the only feasible way to end the "Occupation" by the Arabs and resettle them on the 120,000 sq. km of land the Arab countries confiscated from the terrorized and expelled Jewish families who now were resettled in Israel and comprise over half the population.

Israel cannot continue to rule over a growing and increasingly hostile and radicalized Palestinian Arab population which indoctrinate and commits terror and violence.

- Neither can it, nor should it, allow the establishment of yet another Muslim-majority tyranny. (a terrorist state)

- Nor can it integrate the Arab population who commits terror and violence in Judea-Samaria (and Gaza) into the permanent population of the Jewish state.

For those who like to see how to, here is the paragraph:

Accordingly, the only non-coercive policy that can preserve Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people, and remove the Palestinian-Arabs from Jewish rule, is to set up a system of economic inducements, entailing enticing incentives for them to leave, together with daunting disincentives to stay, and provide non-belligerents and their families an opportunity for a better life elsewhere out of harm's way. That is the only feasible way to end the "Occupation" by the Arabs and resettle them on the 120,000 sq. km of land the Arab countries confiscated from the terrorized and expelled Jewish families who now were resettled in Israel and comprise over half the population.

A heavenly maiden with an orb of gold Sits by the Mediterranean Sea

A heavenly maiden with an orb of gold
Sits by the Mediterranean Sea

She gazes at the sailors and ships
That pass by for eternity
Who are you? fair maiden, they ask
What is your pedigree
I am a Jew, she answers, and that's my destiny
I am called Israel born of steel and fire
I have gathered my children from many lands afar
From East and West and South and North
They came in multitude
And they have made me what I am
In everlasting gratitude
I am their mother and they are my children
That's how we both feel
Israel (my name) is a reality
That adversity could not kill.


Jerusalem - the Ancient City 

If you came to this page directly, you might wish to read a page with an introduction to this section first or start with Jerusalem - The Walls. 
Museum of Israel: model of Jerusalem in the year 66 AD
In 1962-66 archaeologist Michael Avi-Yonah built a model of Jerusalem prior to its almost total destruction in the course of the First Jewish War which ended with the seizure of the Temple by Titus, Emperor Vespasian's son. The event was eventually celebrated by a triumphal arch in the Roman Forum. The model was built when Old Jerusalem was part of Jordan and Jewish archaeologists had not access to it. It was initially developed as embellishment for a hotel. It was moved to the Israeli Museum in 2006. The model includes a large theatre resembling Teatro di Marcello, a facility typical of the Greek/Roman world. 

Museum of Israel: model of Jerusalem in the year 66 AD: the Second Temple
The Second Temple was situated at the centre of a large rectangular portico made up of painted limestone columns which was built by King Herod the Great. Access to the central section of the portico and to the Temple was reserved to Jews. Overall the size and shape of the complex were similar to the temenos (sacred area) of the Temple to Jupiter in Damascus. 

View of Jerusalem from Dominus Flevit on the Mount of Olives; (inset) bell tower of the Franciscan church
In the model the portico surrounding the Temple is situated on higher ground than the rest of the city. As a matter of fact Mount Moriah, the hill which was levelled to build the portico is at a level lower than the rest of the city. Overall Old Jerusalem slopes down from its north-western corner, marked by the bell tower of the Franciscan church, to its south-eastern corner, the terrace where the Temple stood.
The large portico was likely used as a marketplace, as per the episode of the Cleansing of the Temple (John 2 13-16). The episode refers to moneychangers and sellers of doves; these two activities were related to offerings and sacrifices made at the Temple, but probably other trades went on at the portico.
Excavations outside the southern walls
Jerusalem in 66 AD included some neighbourhoods to its south which are outside the XVIth century Ottoman walls. Jerusalem became the capital of the Kingdom of Israel after it was conquered by King David in ca 1000 BC. Recent excavations indicate that David's Jerusalem was located south of the city on a hill opposite the terrace of the Temple. 

Wailing Wall
The First Jewish War was in part a civil war too. Some Jews supported the Romans and in addition the leaders of the revolt fought among themselves, even inside Jerusalem. The Temple and most of the town were destroyed. This event and other national tragedies are mourned every year with a day's fast. Jews do not access the terrace because it is regarded as a deconsecrated area after the destruction of the Temple. They gather to pray at a section of the wall supporting the terrace. Its lower part is still made up by the ancient stones, whereas the upper one is the result of later repairs. 

(left) Museum of Israel: Bust of Emperor Hadrian (bronze head and lead armoury); (right) side arch of a triumphal gate beneath Damascus Gate; it was probably similar to that at Antalya
Jewish affairs were going from bad to worse. The work of construction was continuing in Jerusalem, in spite of the violent opposition of Zealot groups. A certain number of errors had been committed. (..) The Tenth Legion Fretensis has a wild boar for its emblem; when its standard was placed at the city gates, as is the custom, the populace, unused to painted or sculptured images (..), mistook that symbol for a swine, the meat of which is forbidden them, and read into that insignificant affair an affront to the customs of Israel.(..) Governor Tineus Rufus decided to extend to the Jewish practice of circumcision the same severe penalties of the law which I had recently promulgated against castration (and which was aimed especially at cruelties perpetrated upon young slaves for the sake of exorbitant gain or debauch). (..) No people but Israel has the arrogance to confine truth within the narrow limits of a single conception of the divine. (..) I was only the more anxious to make Jerusalem a city like the others, where several races and several beliefs could live in peace; but I was wrong to forget that in any combat between fanaticism and common sense the latter has rarely the upper hand. Marguerite Yourcenar - Memoirs of Hadrian - Translation by Grace Frick in collaboration with the author - Farrar, Strauss and Giroux 1954 - Reprinted in Penguin Classics 2000.
You may wish to learn more about Marguerite Yourcenar and her book on Emperor Hadrian.
Arch built by Hadrian: (left) central arch on Via Dolorosa (the Sorrowful Road which follows the route of Decumanus Maximus, the main east-west street); (right) side arch inside Notre Dame de Sion, the church of a French convent
The French Catholics are building a church on this spot, and with their usual veneration for historical relics, are incorporating into the new such scraps of ancient walls as they have found there.
Mark Twain - The Innocents Abroad - 1869
At the end of the Second Jewish War (132-35) Emperor Hadrian proscribed the Jews from Aelia Capitolina, the town he had founded on the ruins of Jerusalem and which was named after the emperor's first name (Aelius) and the Capitoline Hill, a symbol of Rome. Today it is very difficult to find open references to Aelia Capitolina. For the Jews it is a sort of case of "repressed memory", a condition where a memory has been blocked by an individual due to the high level of stress contained in that memory. The Museum of the History of Jerusalem which is housed in the Citadel does not even mention Aelia Capitolina. 

Lithostrotos: paving stones found under Notre Dame de Sion; (insert) a betting game carved on one of the stones
Aelia Capitolina is a case of "repressed memory" for the Christians too. It was built above the ruins of Jesus' Jerusalem and its remaining monuments indicate that the current, mainly Mameluke, town is some 10 feet above Aelia. The pilgrims who come from all over the world and who sometimes almost re-enact the sufferances of Jesus by carrying heavy crosses and wearing crowns of thorns, prefer not to be aware of the existence of Aelia under the stones of Via Dolorosa.
Inscription in the courtyard of the Church of Flagellation celebrating Emperor Trajan
By and large most of the evidence of Aelia is due to findings which occurred during the construction or enlargement of churches and convents along Via Dolorosa in the north-eastern part of the town. These are now dispersed in the courtyards of several mainly Catholic establishments. 

(above) Double cistern with a Temple to Aesculapius near St. Anne's; (below) relief with hunting scenes found in the area
Hence we proceeded to the supposed site of the pool of Bethesda which is close by the gate of Our Lady Mary. The water now exists no more, but its site is a long valley about 60 feet in depth 300 in length and 100 in breadth. It is overgrown with trees and shrubs and is now used as a common sewer by the inhabitants of the houses built on its brink.
William Turner - Journal of a Tour in the Levant - 1820
Baths are a typical monumental building one expects to find in a Roman town. They were probably located not far from a double cistern near Lion Gate, the eastern gate of Jerusalem. Aelia was supplied with water by a long Roman aqueduct. The presence of a Temple to Aesculapius, god of medicine, near a cistern is due to the importance of bathing and in general of water in treating patients. You may wish to visit the Asklepion of Pergamum to better understand the state-of-the-art medicine at the time of Hadrian. 

Map of the Holy City of Jerusalem: copy of a VIth century mosaic found at Madaba (Jordan): 1) Damascus Gate; 2) Cardo Maximus; 3) Holy Sepulchre; 4) Basilica Nea; 5) Lion Gate; 6) Jaffa Gate
Tabula Peutingeriana (it opens in a separate page), a Vth century map added the words antea dicta Jerusalem(once known as Jerusalem) to Aelia Capitolina (7 in the map), but eventually the ancient name replaced that given by Hadrian. In the mosaic of Madaba Jerusalem was referred to as Holy City. In this map the religious centre of the town was no longer at the ancient Temple (where Hadrian built a Temple to Jupiter), but it had moved to the basilica built on the site of the Holy Sepulchre.
Cardo Maximus
After the Old City was annexed by the Kingdom of (Trans)Jordan in 1950, the Jewish Quarter which stood in the southern part of the city was largely burnt and most of its buildings were pulled down. Excavations carried out to rebuild the quarter led to unearthing a section of Cardo Maximus, the main north-south street of the ancient town. Archaeologists indicate that the columns belong to a Byzantine restoration of the street.
(left) Basilica Nea; (right) one of the capitals
Other excavations carried out in the Jewish Quarter unearthed the foundations of Basilica Nea, a church founded by Emperor Justinian in 540 and shown in the map of Madaba. The accuracy of the map is demonstrated by the column shown near Damascus Gate. That column has disappeared, but for centuries another column stood in that same place to indicate the junction of the two cardi and the gate was also known as the Gate of the Column.
One of the "Arches of the Balances" which surround the Dome of the Rock
In order to gain a real understanding of the wealth of Aelia Capitolina one has to visit Haram ash-Sharif, the Arabic name for the terrace of the Temple, and its Muslim monuments which, similar to many churches of Rome, were built utilizing ancient columns and capitals.
Ancient capitals outside el-Aqsa Library
There is a somewhat extraordinary high standard of execution in the monuments which were built throughout the Roman Empire. This was due to a "division of labour" by which some locations such asAphrodisias provided almost the whole empire with marble capitals and reliefs. The Byzantine capital in the foreground most likely came from Constantinopolis. The image used as background for this page shows a Corinthian capital. 

Broken columns of various stones including green cipollino
Every where about the Mosque of Omar are portions of pillars, curiously wrought altars, and fragments of elegantly carved marble - precious remains of Solomon's Temple. These have been dug from all depths in the soil and rubbish of Mount Moriah, and the Moslems have always shown a disposition to preserve them with the utmost care. M. Twain
Twain was wrong in saying that the columns belonged to the Temple built by King Herod. The columns of the Temple were made up of painted limestone similar to what can be seen at the king's palaces of Masadaand Herodion (they open in a separate page).
The "division of labour" was applied to columns too. The use of coloured columns was very fashionable at Hadrian's time. Pink and grey granite columns came from Egypt, as well as a very precious type of porphyry. Cipollino was quarried in the Greek island of Euboea. Simitthus, in today's Tunisia, provided the whole empire with yellow and red columns.

See these other pages on Jerusalem

The Walls	The Crusader City	The Holy Sepulchre
Haram esh-Sheriff	The Four Quarters	Outside the Walls

Move to:
Introductory Page
Nimrod Castle
Banias (Caesarea Philippi)
Acre (Akko)
Turner's excursion to Kaifah (Haifa)
Tiberias
Holy sites in Galilee
Nazareth
Jaffa
A Glimpse of Tel Aviv